SOME INFO ABOUT MYSELF

Being the selected wisdom of a certain writer of adventure picto-books, Gail Simone.

Following

Ask me anything, anything except that
7 September 12

An Interesting Question

This came up on Twitter and I must admit, I am of two minds about it.

A poster posted a photo link showing a pink Batgirl outfit for very little girls (or boys, if they are so inclined!).

My first reaction wasn’t, “Oh, man, here we go again, enforcing gender roles on children, everything has to be pink for girls, so typical!”

My first reaction was along the lines of, “Oh, that is adorable.”

But was I right, or were the people who said the first thing right?

It’s very interesting…some people immediately objected to the idea of a pink Batgirl outfit. They felt it was forcing girls to be pink and princess-y and all the stereotype stuff.

I see their point and it’s clearly true that that happens a lot.

But I also have a niece who loves superheroes and is simply DRAWN to pink and always has been. If there were a thousand Batgirl costumes and one pink one, there is absolutely no question which one she would choose.

I also have to say, I go to cons all year long, and see adorable kids in Batgirl uniforms, many of which are purchased, not home-made. I have to say I see dozens and dozens in the more traditional colors for every one I see that is pink.

But maybe cons are different. Maybe there are stores where pink is the only choice, and if a little girl wants to be Batgirl, she HAS to be pink. That would bug me.

But I do have a problem seeing the harm, when a little girl has a choice, of letting her make up her own mind. I don’t find the costume problematic in itself.

Am I wrong? Am I missing something? What do you guys think. I admit, I haven’t given it much thought yet so I’m curious to know.

http://www.chasing-fireflies.com/images/28812_p.jpg

  1. baneonatrex said: No, I think if a little girl (or boy, like you said) wants to be pink Batgirl, then let them be pink Batgirl. I certainly wouldn’t choose it, but who am I to stop someone else from doing so?
  2. bewareohmortalsouls reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    ONLY batgirl outfit available...would be perfectly happy.
  3. ealperin reblogged this from mayak46
  4. mayak46 reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    Sometimes I think it’s too easy to get caught up in the medium instead of the actual message. As long as there are...
  5. othemts reblogged this from librarianpirate and added:
    I ran into a similar situation last summer during the Women’s World Cup. Excited about the USA team and the imminent...
  6. piratmisc reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    subject I’m really conflicted about. Because while I’ve met...totally stoked to get a
  7. daidia reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    wasn’t trying to belittle race representation, believe me. my main thought was that
  8. felixitous said: To me, if all the options are available to both genders, then it’s absolutely great! Maybe make some batcostumes in other colors, too! But if the traditional colors are only for boys and the pink only for girls, THEN it’s a problem.
  9. cookiediesel said: Is it okay if I don’t like the costume not because of gender issues, but because it is obviously so poorly constructed?
  10. feministbatgirl said: As a young child, Batgirl was my only on-screen antidote to princess characters. But I only had pink princess merchandise to choose from in stores. I would have loved to have black and yellow Batgirl stuff to play dress-up in instead.
  11. meiran said: I’m a grown woman, but I desperately want Batgirl pajamas and I want them to be purple, not black. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with creating a Batgirl anything that’s in an alternate color scheme, as long as it’s not forced on anyone.
  12. gailsimone reblogged this from hamburgerjack and added:
    Oh, man, I agree, sorry, I felt there were two different points being made there. I didn’t mean to sound like I was...
  13. thebigblackwolfe reblogged this from hamburgerjack
  14. freemasonic-yowl said: But Batgirl doesn’t wear pink…
  15. scribblingface reblogged this from zaataronpita
  16. hamburgerjack reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    Okay that’s a good point but lack of racial representation in toys/media/merchandise is not like a pink batgirl costume....
  17. spiral-shark said: I think the problem with this is that there is no “wrong” or “right” answer between the two, and must be looked at within the larger context which changes constantly depending on the circumstances of the individual, the direct community, culture, etc
  18. zeraphim reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    The thing is that pretending that there...NO differences whatsoever between genders is...
  19. adorababble reblogged this from therearecertainshadesoflimelight
  20. macs-guide-to-the-galaxy reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    can conceptually...BG herself doesn’t wear pink,...can’t...
  21. fullonmonet reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    don’t think there is anything wrong with your reaction....probably stereotypically “girly”...
  22. yibbetstrikesagain reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    choose. So in seeing...outfit, I wouldn’t immediately think ‘oh, gender roles again’ I’d...
Themed by Hunson. Originally by Josh